Inspired by nature. For a natural you.

Free postage within Australia for orders over AUD 66 (Incl. GST)
International Shipping now available.
Free postage within Australia for orders over AUD 66 (Incl. GST)
International Shipping now available.

What you need to know about Calcium

Most people know that Calcium is an important part of any healthy diet. We’re told it helps us to grow and gives us healthy bones from a young age.

It’s important to know some of the details about Calcium and what’s best to ensure you can optimise the benefits.

How much calcium should I be getting?

The official recommendation is 1,000 milligrams (mg) a day for adults ages 19 to 50 and 1,200 mg for those over 50. Those amounts include calcium from all sources: dairy products, other food and drinks, and calcium supplements. However there’s a dissenting point of view that 600 mg to 1,000 mg a day is sufficient and perhaps better for us.

 

How much calcium am I getting if I don’t take a supplement?

A reasonably good diet that includes some fruit and vegetables provides about 200 mg to 300 mg daily — and that’s without any dairy products. A well-rounded diet with some servings of milk and dairy products puts you well into the neighbourhood of 600 mg to 800 mg a day.

 

Is it better to get calcium from supplements or from food?

Studies have repeatedly found that we’re far better off getting most of our nutrients from food rather than from pills. With calcium, it’s more complicated. In many ways, dairy products, and milk in particular, are an ideal source of the mineral. The calcium content is high and easily absorbed. However when dairy comes into the diet, saturated fat comes with it, and high saturated fat intake increases cardiovascular risk. Furthermore, a few studies suggest that dairy food itself increases the risk of certain cancers.

 

You can easily get around the saturated fat problem by buying non-fat dairy products. Some vegetables are a good source of calcium. Some, such as spinach, chard, and a few others also contain oxalate, and the presence of oxalate interferes with the absorption of calcium.

 

Bottom line: food is the preferred way to get a nutrient, calcium included. The best food choices for calcium include non-fat dairy products (in limited amounts), as well as certain types of fish (canned salmon and sardines) and vegetables (collard greens and almonds).

 

If I need a supplement, which one should I take?

Most calcium supplements are made with either calcium carbonate or calcium citrate. Calcium carbonate needs stomach acid to be absorbed, so if it is the source of calcium in your supplement it’s best to take it just before a meal when stomach acid is highest. Calcium citrate isn’t as dependent on stomach acid, so it can be taken any time. People taking medications that reduce stomach acid — such as the proton-pump inhibitors (Prevacid, Prilosec) or the H2 blockers (Tagamet, Zantac) — should take a calcium citrate supplement because lower amounts of stomach acid as a result of these medications mean they won’t digest calcium carbonate effectively.

The big advantage of calcium carbonate over calcium citrate is that it contains twice as much calcium.

 

Make sure you read the labels on the bottles carefully, as sometimes it may seem like both kinds of tablets provide the same amount of calcium, usually 500 mg to 600 mg. But that’s the amount of calcium per “serving” and if you read carefully you’ll see that the serving size for the calcium citrate supplements is usually two tablets, however for the calcium carbonate supplements, it’s generally one.

 

It’s a waste to double the serving size. The body can absorb a 500- or 600-mg dose, however more than that and absorption becomes inefficient. You’ll get about the same amount of calcium by taking 1,000 mg as you would if you stuck with the 500 mg or 600 mg.

 

Does calcium prevent fractures?

High calcium intake does result in higher levels of calcium in the blood, which inhibits bone resorption—the part of the bone tissue “life cycle” in which bone tissue breaks down. If calcium levels in the blood are low, bone resorption can help nudge them back to normal. But in the process, bones get weaker and are more likely to fracture. In theory, keeping calcium levels in the blood high prevents that chain of events from happening.

 

However in several epidemiological studies, including some based at Harvard, people with high calcium intake haven’t, as a group, broken fewer bones than people with skimpy intake. Randomized trials, which have made head-to-head comparisons between calcium and a placebo, have shown some improvement in bone density however not so much in the prevention of fractures. One possible explanation is that in the long run, there are other factors — muscle strength, balance, physical activity, vitamin D intake — that outweigh calcium intake in determining fracture risk.

 

There is disagreement about how much weight to give the negative evidence. Not every finding has been negative. In one important trial, the women who consistently took their calcium pills, along with 400 international units (IU) of vitamin D, did have significantly fewer broken hips. Despite the debate, the official calcium recommendations remain at the 1,000 mg and 1,200 mg level. It’s safe to say that there are now some doubts about whether high calcium intake lives up to its billing as the best way to prevent bone breaks.

 

Many calcium supplements include vitamin D. Could that make a difference?

Vitamin D aids in the absorption of calcium (and phosphorus), however the evidence from studies of calcium and vitamin D combinations shows mixed results.  Part of the problem may be the vitamin D dose. Several important studies used 400 IU, and it may take double that amount of vitamin D to make a big difference in bone health. Most calcium–vitamin D products contain either 200 IU or 400 IU of vitamin D.

 

Vitamin D is believed to have a multitude of benefits, and many of us have less of it in our bodies than we should, partly because we don’t spend much time outdoors. Skin exposed to sunlight generates the active form of the vitamin, thus the “sunshine vitamin” nickname. There’s a school of thought that says we need to ramp up our vitamin D intake to 1,000 IU or more a day and ease off the calcium. Bottom line: Vitamin D may make a difference if included with a calcium supplement.

 

Does high calcium intake cause kidney stones?

About 80% of the time kidney stones are made of calcium, so on the surface it makes sense that calcium intake might cause stones. However studies going back to the 1990s have shown just the opposite: high calcium intake, if it comes from food, makes developing a kidney stone less likely. One possible explanation is that calcium retards the absorption of oxalate, a molecule that often mixes with calcium to cause kidney stones. Oxalate is found in many plant foods, including some varieties of berries, spinach, nuts, and some grains.

 

Several studies have found that calcium supplements, in contrast to calcium from food, are associated with a slight increase in the risk for kidney stones. Researchers have speculated that if people take calcium pills separately from meals, or at just one meal a day (typically breakfast), then calcium may be absent from the gut much of the time and not available for oxalate-blocking duties.

 

Will taking calcium supplements deposit calcium in my arteries?

CT scans show calcium deposits in the atherosclerotic plaques in arteries, so there’s been some concern that high calcium intake might “feed” those deposits. However calcium deposits are a consequence of the inflammatory processes that produce the atherosclerosis and probably have little to do with blood levels of the mineral. The way to avoid calcium deposits in your arteries is to follow a heart healthy lifestyle: exercising, avoiding cigarette smoking, and controlling blood pressure, blood sugar, and cholesterol levels. And calcium might help in that regard because it seems to help lower blood pressure and cholesterol levels.

 

The results of a New Zealand study caused some concern because it showed that women who took calcium (1,000 mg daily of calcium citrate) were more, not less, likely to have heart attacks and other cardiovascular problems, compared with those who took a placebo. However, as the researchers noted, this was a preliminary finding that might prompt more research and far from a final verdict on calcium and cardiovascular risk.

 

Is there really a connection between calcium and cancer?

The good news: studies have pretty consistently shown that people with high calcium intake and lots of dairy products in their diet are less likely to get colon cancer. Less certain are findings that suggest some protective effect for lung and breast cancer. The bad news? A number of studies have linked calcium and dairy intake to ovarian cancer and advanced-stage prostate cancer. However, it is important to keep in mind that the evidence is suggestive, not definitive, and a long way off from being proven.

RELATED HERB VALLEY PRODUCTS

 

Herb Valley's Sunshine Supplement offers both calcium and Vitamin D. The Vitamin D in this synergistic mixture helps with calcium absorption and makes the product an effective calcium supplement.